Guardianships after Changes to Utah Code, Section 75-5-303, A.K.A., My Morning in Probate Court

Recently, the Utah Legislature determined intellectually-incapacitated adults don’t need a lawyer when their parents request guardianship over them. This change was codified in Utah Code, Section 75-5-303(d).

Why Section 75-5-303(d) Is a Joke

This was a horrible idea for a number of reasons:

  1. Almost all attorneys who help families and incapacitated adults with guardianships thought this law was poorly thought out and just bad. Same with advocacy groups who help these individuals.
  2. It creates a system in which incapacitated adults have essentially no legal due process rights. Guardianship is a very serious matter. It gives one person (or multiple people) almost total control over another person. This authority extends to money, medical decisions, living conditions and locations, end-of-life decisions, etc., etc., etc. When you make a determination like this, someone with an IQ of 40 really needs some protection. This law strips away any protection from the most vulnerable population in our society. That’s not right and not good.
  3. Piggybacking on #2, this change takes away any outside determination that someone who wants total control over another human being is appropriate for that role. In guardianship, you have to establish two things: (1) the person over whom guardianship is sought is actually incapacitated, and (2) the person asking for guardianship is appropriate. Without an attorney for the incapacitated person, there is no one there to ensure the parents asking for guardianship are, in fact, appropriate to act as guardians.

(Note: My understanding of the origin of this bill is a parent thought it insulting they had to pay someone to act as their child’s attorney, so the attorney could then determine if that parent was appropriate to act as guardian of their own child. It might well be insulting, but, with all respect, who cares? The parent’s emotions are not important. What’s important is the safety and protection of the intellectually impaired adult. Before I was an attorney, I worked for many years with this exact population. I have seen parents do terrible things to their intellectually-impaired children: financial exploitation (stealing Social Security Disability money was always a favorite), sexual exploitation, physical abuse, social isolation, and emotional abuse. Thankfully, it didn’t happen often — the vast majority of parents on the up and up and just want to help their kids through life — , but it happened much more often than people think.)

  1. I could go on, but you get the point.

This Morning at Probate Court

Now, I didn’t write this post to rant about 75-5-303(d)’s tortured logic, although I think the change is an abomination and should be repealed ASAP. Instead, I wanted to write about my experience in probate court this morning.

I do a number of guardianships for families and have for years, usually representing these intellectually impaired adults. This morning was the first day I have been in court since the law came in to effect and parents were finalizing guardianships without attorneys representing their intellectually-impaired children.

The first family went up to the podium in front of the judge (a very good and reasonable judge) with a child that said, I believe, one word. The judge recognized there was no attorney representing the parents, so he swore them in and asked them questions. One of the questions was, “Have you spoken to [child’s name] about the guardianship and explained things to him?” They replied they had tried, but he didn’t really understand anything. Then the judge asked [child’s name] if he knew why he was there. A grunt was the response. The judge then asked if he was okay with his parents having guardianship. The intellectually-impaired child responded with a, “Yes.” The judge asked the parents why they didn’t hire an attorney. The responded with, “Because he’s obviously disabled.” There was no discussion regarding whether the parents were appropriate to act as guardians. The judge then concluded that under the statute, the parents had met their burden and no counsel was required.

The second family went through much the same process, except their child couldn’t speak at all. It was exceedingly obvious to everyone in the court (including about twenty-five attorneys) this intellectually-impaired adult had absolutely no idea what was going on. When the judge asked if they had spoken to their child about guardianship, they admitted they hadn’t even tried. “He’s disabled and doesn’t understand anything,” was the exact response. That was also the response when the judge asked why they hadn’t hired an attorney to represent their son’s interests. The judge approved the guardianship (a plenary guardianship). This person’s IQ couldn’t have been above 30.

Each of these guardianships took less than two minutes.

The whole thing was a circus show. (Not because of the judge. Let me be clear about this: the judge was just doing what the statute tells him to do. He was bound and he did his job with dignity. The problem is with the Utah legislators who thought stripping the intellectually impaired of all due process rights was a stellar idea.) I put my head in my hands as the rights of these individuals was taken away without the slightest oversight. I have never been so embarrassed to be an attorney in Utah as I was this morning.

The saddest thing is the average cost of representation for these individuals is $300 to $400. Apparently, due process for society’s most vulnerable adults is worth less than what most people spend on gas every month.

Protect Your Money And Your Family

We remove fear associated with divorce, protect your money & maximize time with your kids!

We're here to help. Let's determine your best options.

Call Us 24//7 at 801-685-9999 to Speak with a Live Representative

Utah Divorce FAQs
Top 100 Divorce Blog
What Clients Are Saying…
BrownLaw icon
Excellent
Brown Family Law
4.8
Based on 912 reviews
Nathaniel Garrabrandt and Brown Family Law is where I send people who are seeking Divorce. Highly professional and compassionate. Thank you!
I cannot say enough good about my experience with Brown Family Law. Ray Hingson and paralegal Carren did an excellent job with my case. I will definitely use this firm again for any legal issues.
I have worked with Andrew Christensen many times in a variety of situations. I am very impressed with his friendly demeanor in a difficult situation. I would highly recommend him to you without any reservations.
Highly recommend Brown Family Law. Life is hard, divorce is harder, and Andrew Christensen is your guy to help you through to the other side.
When you’re going through a tough time and need legal help, this firm isn’t just a one-person operation. It’s a team of attorneys who work together to support you every step of the way. So you’re not just getting a lawyer, you’re getting a legal team behind you.

Navigating the legal system was a steep learning curve for me, and my situation was fairly complex. What stood out about this law firm was the way multiple attorneys collaborated to address my case. It wasn’t just one person working in isolation, but a team supporting each other to find the best path forward. That kind of collective effort is a real strength, especially in hard out complex situations like mine.

There was one issue I felt should have had a different outcome with the court. When I brought it up, the team responded in a very professional and respectful manner, which I truly appreciated. It came to my understanding that the legal system sometimes works in a way that is distant than I thought. This was presented to me in a way that someone outside of the legal system could understand.

In my experience, this firm takes the time to not only assist you, but also help you understand why things are happening. That made a big difference for me, and it’s something that really sets them apart.
Response from the owner:David, thank you for our conversation and taking the time to leave this review.
My experience with Jennifer and Brown Family Law was nothing short of amazing. From the very beginning of my initial consultation all the through until my case was settled, I was well taken care of and updated every step of the way. I felt like my team genuinely cared about the outcome of my case, which was refreshing. You get what you pay for, and Brown Family was worth every penny. To say I highly recommend this group is an understatement.
Response from the owner:Thank you very much, Steve. Glad Jennifer took good care of you.
Andrew Christensen was a great divorce lawyer. He is very experienced, professional, and was great to work with during this difficult process.
Response from the owner:Casey, thank you and so glad Andrew served you well.
Made my divorce quick and painless. 5 months ago I was feeling very overwhelmed. There was legal issues with protective orders, my ex wife had taken my kids to another country without my consent, I was in way over my head. After speaking with brown law they calmed my nerves took over my case. A few video calls and 5 months later my divorce is finalized with a fair outcome for everyone. It was easy and stress fee, it didn’t even feel like I was going through a divorce.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much, Brian. Sorry you went through all of that, but glad we were able to help.
Jennifer was excellent! She was always responsive and kept me updated on my case. while the billing was a little different from what I expected, her expertise was invaluable. I highly recommend her. And I appreciate everything she's done for me and may case.
Response from the owner:Jennifer, thank you and glad Jennifer was able to help you and kept you updated.
Going through the divorce process can be overwhelming, exhausting and emotionally draining.
I did my homework to find the perfect lawyer to represent me knowing I could have peace of mind throughout the process.
Leilani Whitmer and her paralegal Idania did not disappoint. Their professionalism and dedication to my case was outstanding and fair.
Leilani had just had surgery a few days before mediation and showed up on crutches and ready to go. That’s dedication!!!
I am highly recommending them to anyone looking to feel at ease during a difficult time.
Response from the owner:Lesia, glad Leilani and Dani took such good care of you.
yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7

Categories