What Are the Effects of Changing Schools Mid-Year during a Divorce?

One all-too-common tactic used in Utah divorces is one parent taking the kids in the middle of the school year and moving them miles away to a new school. Essentially, they change schools in the middle of the year.

The thought is that the parent who moves the kids will have an upper hand in the divorce.

Quite often in Utah divorce, this tactic backfires.

Judges see this behavior as a power play to keep the kids away from the other parent, and as something that disrupts children’s lives.

Beyond Utah divorce tactics and what judges think, doing this to kids is not a good idea.

Taking kids from their schools and putting them in another one, especially during a turbulent time like divorce, tends to hurt kids, both scholastically and emotionally.

We’ve dealt with these types of moves many times, and we’ve compiled some research findings to help Utah divorce courts see how damaging changing schools can be on kids.

Here is a look at some of that research:

Summary of Research on Changing Schools

Study 1

Gasper, DeLuca, and Estacion, Switching Schools: Reconsidering the Relationship Between School Mobility and High School Dropout, Am Educ. Res. J. June 2012, at 14-15.

Like previous research, we find that just under 30% of high school students attend more than one high school, and the students who change schools are more likely to drop out. Consistent with other studies that examine the backgrounds of mobile students, we find that the students who are most likely to switch schools are also those students who are operating with a number of existing risk factors, such as behavioral problems, lower test scores, more school absences, a non­intact family, previous substance use, lower incomes and more residential mobility.”

“We found that the differences in dropout rates between switchers and stayers could be largely accounted for by family structure and previous behavior and academic performance.”

Study 2

Jeffrey Grigg, School Enrollment Changes and Student Achievement Growth: A Case Study in Educational Disruption and Continuity, Sociology of Education, http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0038040712441374, at 401.

This article expands the definition of student mobility to encompass all situations in which a student finds himself or herself in a new school. It finds not only that these experiences are more prevalent than most estimates of mobility would suggest but also that in all cases the changes in school enrollment were detrimental to the student’s achievement growth as measured by test scores. The change in MNPS enrollment policies as it achieved unitary status induced variation in compulsory school changes that allowed for a robust estimate of the effect of changing schools. Although the phenomena are not strictly uniform, the results were remarkably consistent in both reading and mathematics and across all types of mobility except expulsion, suggesting that school changes disrupt a child’s educational development at least in the short term. Disadvantaged students experience these disruptions more frequently during the course of their education, which may lead to an accumulating deficit.

Study 3

Burkam, Lee, and Dwyer, School Mobility in the Early Elementary Grades: Frequency and Impact From Nationally-Representative Data, Workshop on the Impact of Mobility and Change on the Lives of Young Children, Schools, and Neighborhoods, June 29-30, 2009, at 2–3, 4.

Although structural reasons for changing schools do occur, and are therefore important to attend to, it is equally important to consider reasons for school change that are related to the family. . . . School changes also may occur as a result of residential mobility due to a change in the family’s situation; this could include positive changes, such as a better job, a better residence, or moving to be near family (Crowley, 2003) or negative disruptions within the family, such as divorce, job loss, economic downturns, or death in the family (among others) (Crowley, 2003; Rumberger et al., 1999).

Taken together, the majority of the literature on school mobility suggests that school change has a negative influence on academic achievement, academic progress, and non-academic outcomes.

. . .

Discontinuity for mobile children. Whether a school change is strategic or reactive, when a child changes schools, he or she experiences what some researchers call an “ecological transition” (Mehana & Reynolds, 2004; Temple & Reynolds, 1999). This term, borrowed from Bronfenbrenner’s ecological theory, has been defined as “changes in the settings, roles, or expectations of a developing person” (Temple & Reynolds, 1999). These changes create discontinuity in a child’s academic and social environment. Academically, a child is likely to experience a mismatch between his or her old and new schools in the curriculum (Rumberger et al., 1999), teachers, academic standards, and expectations for classroom behavior (Ingersoll, Scamman, & Echerling, 1989; Mehana & Reynolds, 2004). Some researchers have suggested that these changes might be particularly harmful during early schooling, as mobile children may miss exposure to critical conceptual knowledge that forms the foundation of later learning (Kerbow, 1996). In addition to discontinuity of educational experiences, school change can also disrupt important social networks with peers, teachers, and other adults. An emerging body of researchers have adopted Coleman’s notion of social capital when considering the implications of school mobility, suggesting that school moves diminish social capital by severing social relationships between children, parents, and their teachers (Gruman et al., 2008; Pribesh & Downey, 1999; South, Haney, & Bose, 2007).

Study 4

Schwartz, Stiefel, & Cordes, Moving Matters: The Causal Effect of Moving Schools on Student Performance, Institute for Education and Social Policy, Working Paper #01-15, March 2015, at 7.

Conversely, moves made in the middle of the school year are likely to have more deleterious effects than those made during the summer – that is, between school years – because such mid-year moves will be more disruptive to peer networks and the learning process, whereas summer moves allow a student to begin the school year with new classmates.

Call Brown Family Law

If you find yourself facing a divorce, please call 801.685.9999 for a legal in-person consultation, or use our online scheduling tool.

Protect Your Money And Your Family

We remove fear associated with divorce, protect your money & maximize time with your kids!

We're here to help. Let's determine your best options.

Call Us 24//7 at 801-685-9999 to Speak with a Live Representative

Utah Divorce FAQs
Top 100 Divorce Blog
What Clients Are Saying…
BrownLaw icon
Excellent
Brown Family Law
4.8
Based on 912 reviews
Nathaniel Garrabrandt and Brown Family Law is where I send people who are seeking Divorce. Highly professional and compassionate. Thank you!
I cannot say enough good about my experience with Brown Family Law. Ray Hingson and paralegal Carren did an excellent job with my case. I will definitely use this firm again for any legal issues.
I have worked with Andrew Christensen many times in a variety of situations. I am very impressed with his friendly demeanor in a difficult situation. I would highly recommend him to you without any reservations.
Highly recommend Brown Family Law. Life is hard, divorce is harder, and Andrew Christensen is your guy to help you through to the other side.
When you’re going through a tough time and need legal help, this firm isn’t just a one-person operation. It’s a team of attorneys who work together to support you every step of the way. So you’re not just getting a lawyer, you’re getting a legal team behind you.

Navigating the legal system was a steep learning curve for me, and my situation was fairly complex. What stood out about this law firm was the way multiple attorneys collaborated to address my case. It wasn’t just one person working in isolation, but a team supporting each other to find the best path forward. That kind of collective effort is a real strength, especially in hard out complex situations like mine.

There was one issue I felt should have had a different outcome with the court. When I brought it up, the team responded in a very professional and respectful manner, which I truly appreciated. It came to my understanding that the legal system sometimes works in a way that is distant than I thought. This was presented to me in a way that someone outside of the legal system could understand.

In my experience, this firm takes the time to not only assist you, but also help you understand why things are happening. That made a big difference for me, and it’s something that really sets them apart.
Response from the owner:David, thank you for our conversation and taking the time to leave this review.
My experience with Jennifer and Brown Family Law was nothing short of amazing. From the very beginning of my initial consultation all the through until my case was settled, I was well taken care of and updated every step of the way. I felt like my team genuinely cared about the outcome of my case, which was refreshing. You get what you pay for, and Brown Family was worth every penny. To say I highly recommend this group is an understatement.
Response from the owner:Thank you very much, Steve. Glad Jennifer took good care of you.
Andrew Christensen was a great divorce lawyer. He is very experienced, professional, and was great to work with during this difficult process.
Response from the owner:Casey, thank you and so glad Andrew served you well.
Made my divorce quick and painless. 5 months ago I was feeling very overwhelmed. There was legal issues with protective orders, my ex wife had taken my kids to another country without my consent, I was in way over my head. After speaking with brown law they calmed my nerves took over my case. A few video calls and 5 months later my divorce is finalized with a fair outcome for everyone. It was easy and stress fee, it didn’t even feel like I was going through a divorce.
Response from the owner:Thank you so much, Brian. Sorry you went through all of that, but glad we were able to help.
Jennifer was excellent! She was always responsive and kept me updated on my case. while the billing was a little different from what I expected, her expertise was invaluable. I highly recommend her. And I appreciate everything she's done for me and may case.
Response from the owner:Jennifer, thank you and glad Jennifer was able to help you and kept you updated.
Going through the divorce process can be overwhelming, exhausting and emotionally draining.
I did my homework to find the perfect lawyer to represent me knowing I could have peace of mind throughout the process.
Leilani Whitmer and her paralegal Idania did not disappoint. Their professionalism and dedication to my case was outstanding and fair.
Leilani had just had surgery a few days before mediation and showed up on crutches and ready to go. That’s dedication!!!
I am highly recommending them to anyone looking to feel at ease during a difficult time.
Response from the owner:Lesia, glad Leilani and Dani took such good care of you.
yH5BAEAAAAALAAAAAABAAEAAAIBRAA7

Categories